B2 — Upper Intermediate
Google is facing challenges as more people use AI tools and social media instead of traditional search. As search habits change and users rely on direct answers, concerns are growing about the future of web traffic, online content, and Google’s search dominance.
Watch the video and find out about how AI search is changing the web, why fewer users are visiting websites, and what it could mean for the future of online information.
Vocabulary Questions:
- What does “closed-loop” mean? “Google is transforming from a gateway to the internet into a closed-loop answer machine.”Use the word in a sentence.
- What does “feedstock” mean? ”Publishers created content, Google helped people find it, and the traffic flowed back to the source. Now, that relationship has shifted. The web is less a partner than a feedstock.” Use the word in a sentence.
- What does “paywall” mean? ”Doubt and cynicism become the default. That’s not how human knowledge is supposed to develop. Now, curiosity is run by gatekeepers and paywalls.” Use the word in a sentence.
Discussion Questions:
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of AI providing answers directly in search results?
- Do you think it is fair for AI search tools to use information from websites without sending users to those sites? Why or why not?
- How could the decline in website revenue impact the quality and availability of online information?
- How might AI-powered search change the future of the internet and online publishing?
- What responsibility do technology companies have in protecting the sustainability of the online content ecosystem?
- Do you prefer getting quick AI-generated answers or visiting websites for more detailed information? Why?
6 replies on “Google Just Killed Websites”
VOCABULARY QUESTIONS
1. What does “closed-loop” mean? “Google is transforming from a gateway to the internet into a closed-loop answer machine.”Use the word in a sentence.
Closed-loop: type of system that monitors the output and regulates it according to certain feedback in order to maintain a desired state.
Example: The fridge’s cooling closed-loop system keeps your food at a desired temperature, even if you open constantly its doors.
Example 2 (metaphoric): Our conversation became a closed loop, with each of us reinforcing our own views instead of communicating.
2. What does “feedstock” mean? ”Publishers created content, Google helped people find it, and the traffic flowed back to the source. Now, that relationship has shifted. The web is less a partner than a feedstock.” Use the word in a sentence.
Feedstock: material used as an input to obtain a desired product.
Example: Only a fraction of society consume tiktok reels as feedstock to design own ideas, whereas the vast majority directly copies them.
3. What does “paywall” mean? ”Doubt and cynicism become the default. That’s not how human knowledge is supposed to develop. Now, curiosity is run by gatekeepers and paywalls.” Use the word in a sentence.
Paywall: a system designed to restrict access to online content by requiring users to pay a subscription or membership fee.
Example: While I understand the rationale behind paywalls on news websites, it is nevertheless frustrating to be unable to access articles freely.
Discussion Questions:
1. What are the advantages and disadvantages of AI providing answers directly in search results?
Not only do AI-generated answers provide immediate information, but they are also concise and well summarized. As a result, productivity may increase because people spend less time searching for information. Nevertheless, this system may be fostering the impatience that characterizes modern society. We no longer value the process; our focus is solely on the outcome. Consequently, individuals may learn less, develop fewer original ideas, and become less empathetic towards others while expecting everything to be available instantly. Rather than prioritizing collective progress and the well-being of society as a whole, we are becoming increasingly self-centred in the way we manage our time and pursue our goals. In my view, this contributes to the stress of everyday life, which can ultimately lead to mental health issues.
In a nutshell, it seems that we are moving towards an increasingly automated society that often acts without sufficient reflection or perspective.
2. Do you think it is fair for AI search tools to use information from websites without sending users to those sites? Why or why not?
I completely disagree with the abuse of AI search tools from websites by stealing their information without anything in exchange. Websites represent the core knowledge of society. Knowledge always have been transmitted between individuals because of different types of bonds: family, friendship, paid education… and this knowledge may represent information discovered in past. Modern society used websites to allow this information to be globally shared. That’s why I solely expect AI search tools to reward it by at least sending users to those sites. If not, the knowledge-generators would lose their viewers and, consequently, their possible motive to share data. In other words, information would be kept and finally lost.
As I see it, whenever we buy a book to obtain information and learn, we have to pay for it, right? The same for AI search tools who require subscriptions fees in order to provide the best answers.
3. How could the decline in website revenue impact the quality and availability of online information?
With the decline in website revenue, we risk stifling new websites that provide actual knowledge. As a result, online information would not be constantly updated, becoming unreliable outdated. In that moment, free information will die and knowledge will be privatized.
4. How might AI-powered search change the future of the internet and online publishing?
While big companies will be able to acquire paywall systems to avoid AI consulting their websites, small companies or bloggers specialized in an area of expertise will disappear. The lost of the last, may decrease the number of websites and internet and users would not surf it. Instead, they will rely on AI-powered search engines. Consequently, the one that pays a better subscription will be able to obtain more complete results and have the possibility to better understand the concepts asked for. And that’s a parallelism with society: the growing wealth gap that allows richer individuals to have access to better services now will have more access to information.
5. What responsibility do technology companies have in protecting the sustainability of the online content ecosystem?
Technology companies should encourage users to create its own content by rewarding them monetarily or providing direct eye-catching links to their websites. Rather than providing the complete answer upfront, a strategically placed and visually prominent link could encourage users to consult the source directly, increasing traffic to the website and promoting deeper engagement with the content.
6. Do you prefer getting quick AI-generated answers or visiting websites for more detailed information? Why?
To be honest, I do prefer getting quick AI-generated answers. Nevertheless, I only use it to obtain fast responses to simple and direct questions. Whenever I do have to completely understand and learn a topic, I normally digest the detailed information from websites. This way, I am able to acquire the information since quick AI-generated answers are easily forgotten.
You are so doing well, so keep trying and do your best in every writing activity.
You can express this idea more effectively by writing:
Vocabulary Questions:
1. This office is guarded 24 hours a day by closed-loop equipment.
2. This factory uses different types of feedstocks to create its components.
3. She couldn’t access crucial data locked behind paywalls.
Discussion Questions:
1. The main advantage is that you don’t have to visit websites with irrelevant information for you. On the contrary, webpages providers will lose visitors.
2. I think it is not fair for providers because they are likely losing visitors who may want to navigate into websites looking for additional services.
3. It could impact negatively because if these websites don’t earn money they will be forced to close and the amount of online information will be lower and it will likely affect specially to smaller companies.
4. The website designers will have to know better which parameters are taking into account by AI-powered search engines to increase their websites information into searching results.
5. In my opinion, tech companies should offer higher levels of security so that companies aren’t afraid to hold all types of data into their servers.
6. It will depend on what I was looking for. If I only need general information about the topic, it would be enough an AI-generated answer. But if I wanted to look at additional services offered by the company, maybe I would prefer to visit the website instead.
Welcome to PE Blog! Great job starting to practice your writing.
Here is how this answer can be written better:
Keep going with this exercise.
Vocabulary:
1) “closed-loop” mean: close system that can be use in technology, but the original meaning was created into electric system.
I have attended to a conference were a closed-loop was used to monitoring the security.
2) “feedstock”: raw material or product input.
The feedstock for electric car is lithium, it is the key part of the batteries, some countries in Latin America have the large production of this mineral.
3) “paywall” : wall or kind of firewall that’s require payment to get access (subscriptions).
Nowadays many services requires paywall, such as: TV, newspapers, university publications, etc.
Discussion Questions:
1) Advantages or disadvantages, will depend on your business model or company size, for small companies that rely on web search services, will be a huge impact, because they will disappear. The advantage for the consumers, by using AI, is that the search will manage internally and will offer multiples options y just few seconds.
2) In my opinion it is not fair, considering that it was a services that was provided and boosted by the web services companies, in some cases, the costumer pay to accelerate or to score their company in the first positions. But it is clear that there were not a business contract for many years or services agreement in places, that´s why the web services companies, can decide from one day to other to change ther business model.
3)The decline in website revenue will have a sever impact to small business, because they will not be available any longer, they have to migrate o transform, a look for the ways that through the IA model could present their business and might require some additional invements in licences or paywall.
4)AI-Powered will change many things, not only the search process and publishing, it will force to look for a new different type of marketing or publishing tools to promote the companies, internet so far it is the data that feeds the IA, and information needs to be updated.
5) Most of the online content was feed as a voluntary decision and for free (the majority). The website, content and data provided it is used by the technologies companies to training the AI models. The have many responsibilities in terms of IP (Intellectual Property) and the usage of this content without the authorization of the creator.
6) That will depend, I use AI-generated answers if need to do a massive search and summary, but if I need to validate the sources, I go to the website to review the articule or whitepaper.
Impressive work! It’s wonderful to see you making an effort to improve your English writing skills.
See how this response can be revised: